S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Review the latest concerts you have listened to.
Post Reply
SrinathK
Posts: 2481
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10

S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Post by SrinathK »

Vocal : S Aishwarya
Vocal support : S Saundarya
Violin: Dr. M Narmadha
Mridangam : B Sivaraman
Ghatam : Samyukta Sriram
Double tambura

Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018, 4:30 P.m

Live review : Updated as concert progresses

Song list:
1) dakshinamoorthy invocation
2) vAtApi ganapatim - hamsadhwani - Adi - Muthuswami - S - Swaras at karAmbujapAsha beejApuram
3) tera teeyaga rAda - gaULipantu - Adi (1/2 eDuppu) - Thyagaraja
4)Ananda naTam AduvAr - pUrvikalyAni - rUpaka - Neelakanta Sivan - R, S
5) dEvAdi dEva sadAshivA - sindhu rAmakriya - Adi (1 1/2 eDuppu) - Thyagaraja
6) shlOka and O ranga shAyee - kAmbhOji - R, S at bhUlOka vaikunTham, mini TA
7) maitreem bhajata - yamunA kalyAni, kApi - Adi (1/2 eDuppu) - H H Chandrasekhara Saraswati Mahaswamigal of Kanchi Math


And I am back for the 2nd time today, this time at Arkay. Given that we need to get brahma muhurta tickets for buying tickets (yes, that was not a mistake) at MA for RaGa, I instead found another pair of sisters to listen to. And who else?

Arkay Convention Centre is a small hall so I'm like literally 5 ft away from the stage up close and personal. The time slot is short, so I expect about 6 items at the very most.

After the invocation, Aishwariya took off with vAtApi ganapatim. None of the severe voice issues from the last time, though there's still a small rasp and still not as crystal clear as it was in her Academy concert where it was like polished gold. Nevertheless, this promises to be good. Sureshvv will be pleased to know I have spotted another lady on the ghatam, so he better revise his probability estimate. Aishwariya sometimes let Saundarya through in the madhymakAla portions. Kalpanaswaras were sarvalaghu at karAmbujapAsha beejApuram, with a simple ending.

Next up came tera teeyaga rAda, rendered with Aishwarya singing in the lower octave and Saundarya in the upper octave in the pallavi.

Aishwarya then took up pUrvikalyAni for elaboration. Neat and tidy with taan like brighas and flashes of moving phrases. The sore throat is creeping in though and it's taking out chunks of her upper octave range and part of the lower. Still, fortunately it hasn't hurt her brighas. Dr. Narmadha played a detailed and soulful essay in her reply with the trademark big slow jharus and one finger brighas.

The autocorrect is playing havoc here, even after I think I have successfully disabled it.

The kriti is Ananda naTam Aduvar. The madhymakAla of the anupallavi was sung in 3 speeds (slow chatushra, tisra, and tisra 2x speeds) which was well done. Swaras were taken up at naTam AduvAr thillai and Ananda as well, with nice replies by Dr. Narmadha including tossing the final kOrvai back like a shadow. A naDai bhedam to khanDa naDai swaras was well executed by Aishwarya. After another round of sarvalaghu swaras, another naDai bhedam to tisra naDai this time. That sore throat is getting a bit worse, but the sarvalaghu swaras are able to manage it in the pauses. The final kOrvai was executed in 2 speeds and well done. Not many musicians are so comfortable singing sarvalaghu in other naDais, and can't do the change as elegantly as this, it's harder than what Aishwarya makes it look. Dr. Narmadha reproduced the tisra naDai portion in her reply.

The next number was another MS special, devAdi dEva in sindhurAmakriya, a composition of Thyagaraja, with this being one of those Thyagaraja exclusive rAgas. Saundarya is excelling at filling up and supporting her sister. A nice closing pattern from the percussion brought that to a close.

Then an alApana of kAmbhoji. Aishwarya took it gently with this one, focusing on more gentle and sowkhyam laden phrases. Unfortunately thanks to that sore throat, we could not hear her crescendos and usually effortless brighas and range in the upper octave today. Do I sense a hint of O Ranga shAyee coming? Could be. Dr. Narmadha gave a superb reply with some heavy one finger slides and when she played back the pallavi passage, it was going to be O Ranga shAyee no doubt.

Following the shloka, the sisters took up the kriti with Saundarya singing in the upper octave. The pallavi never fails to impress me with the grandeur of the royal sleeper reclining on his serpent bed. What a genius Thyagaraja must have been to compose a kriti like this. The sisters patiently went through every sangati with a lot of sensitivity to the gamakAs.

Given time constraints and the sore throat, neraval was skipped and it was straight to the swaras. Dr. Narmadha was following Aishwarya like a shadow in the swaras. The good news is that her throat got better with the slow speed singing, at least the upper octave opened up by a couple of notes, which was what we were hoping for, so the 2nd speed swaras started off smoothly. A long passage ended on D2 which is where the kuraippu portion began. Aishwarya has some good imagination and elegance in swaras, never repeating a pattern, it's proving to become a forte. A naDai bhedam to tisra naDai made a brief appearance. And then a chatushra naDai 2x burst as well - looks like voice recovered enough for this. She finished off with the same kOrvai MS Amma used for her Carnegie Hall rendition of this kriti.

The tani Avartanam by Sh. B Sivaraman and Samyuktha Sriram was a mini one - with farans, mOhra and kOrvai. Interestingly the kOrvai was a small variation of the same one played at MS Amma's UN concert. The two also gave sowkhyam filled and unobtrusive support throughout the concert. I believe Samyuktha was the same vidushi that sureshvv had mentioned about in another concert. She did well in the fillers, playing with delicacy.

The concert then concluded with maitreem bhajata.

PS : I was later told it was in fact the same virus and it was a nasty, nasty infection that Aishwarya's not yet fully recovered from, even after a month. Best wishes for a speedy recovery. My experience, voice always gets a bit better after recovering from an infection :)

As for me, I still haven't found a cure for autocorrect. :(
Last edited by SrinathK on 25 Dec 2018, 20:35, edited 6 times in total.

ark07
Posts: 47
Joined: 08 Feb 2018, 14:17

Re: S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Post by ark07 »

The accompanists on Mridangam and Ghatam were B. Sivaraman and the young Samyuktha Sriram, who is from the USA.

SrinathK
Posts: 2481
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10

Re: S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Post by SrinathK »

Thank you. I missed that, so couldn't include earlier. Will add.

sureshvv
Posts: 5542
Joined: 05 Jul 2007, 18:17

Re: S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Post by sureshvv »

Can't believe you are bloviating :) all this live! I can barely squeeze in two sentences per item sung.

SrinathK
Posts: 2481
Joined: 13 Jan 2013, 16:10

Re: S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Post by SrinathK »

I think I need to get a Macbook air or some ultracompact and type for real. My fingers are complaining twaddling on a smartphone.

thanjavooran
Posts: 3049
Joined: 03 Feb 2010, 04:44

Re: S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Post by thanjavooran »

Srinath,
Many thanks for the crisp review. Good song list. All Vocalists' great asset only voice. Pray for speedy recovery.
With wishes,
Thanjavooran
25 12 2018

cienu
Posts: 2392
Joined: 04 Feb 2010, 11:40

Re: S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Post by cienu »

It was indeed a pleasure to see Srinath and Pattamma after the concert. :D
Kindly find below 2 pictures

A.picture of the concert.
Image
My daughters were delighted to take a picture with the Great violin Maestro Sri V S Narasimhan after the kutcheri
Image


pattamaa
Posts: 750
Joined: 22 Nov 2009, 10:24

Re: S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Post by pattamaa »

Nothing to write after a brilliant review by srinath would you eat any eatables that we eat every day after drinking amrutham ?

pattamaa
Posts: 750
Joined: 22 Nov 2009, 10:24

Re: S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Post by pattamaa »

this is my "experience" not a review ! Beware

1. Got delayed to concert... started listening youtube live while on train. Vatapi ganapathim was going on, with nice and neat swaras.

2. therya teeyaka radha was well executed with Saudarya effectively using upper octave to create "That blissful" effect. MS Amma and radha mami sang this song once in front of balaji in thirupathi, while curtain was closed !!! Same effect here !

3. Poorvikalyani - i cound't concentrate much, missed key phrases, need to listen again. the keerthana was another perfect ! loved brilliant nadai variations in jathi which srinath talks above.

4. devadi deva - Sathguru thyagaraja swami composition - another gem... Gowri akka says in a lecdem - as i recollect (may be wrong - once gowri akka woke up MS Amma in her sleep - she could correct akka and sing perfect sangathis ! - also how to split - she sang as "deve sapita" and amma correcting as "devesa pita" !!

5. despite voice trouble, Aishwarya sang brilliant kambodhi, with arresting mandara and madhya sthayi sancharas. I was thiking of thiruvadi charanam (may be another day - ceinu anna - and do text me in advance !!!) - O Rangasaayi has all sangathis intact in the same way MS amma and radha mami sung.. Here again, saundarya effectively used upper octave to create srirangam effect. Every single time, these days - lord ranganatha remind me to come and have darshan - last two weeks plus (right form Master Narayanan chamber concert - where he sang - ranganayakam and raju vedala), and today O Rangasaayi !!!!!!!!!

6. A personal annectode - bought 5 calenders of 2019 with mahaswami with few people in mind. But definitely ceinu anna wasn't in my mind (sorry anna !!) and put those calenders in car. As i got down from car, a flash occurred in mind - took a piece with me. I was sitting in right side - behind narmada akka - one elderly lady sitting next to ceinu anna - left during kambodhi. and just when tani avarthanam started, i sat next to anna (totally unplanned), and just when aishwarya sang last few lines in maithreem bhajatha - handed over mahaswami calender to anna (while just before i was thinking i should give to Aishwarya after concert). All such things happen due to divine intervention, in a divine concert to divine people only.

7. Was fortunate to interview ceinu anna outside Arkay convention. Pleasently surprised to learn his paternal great grand father taught samsrutam to mahaperiyava ! Recorded that and uploaded in youtube

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xbJ4pv ... e=youtu.be


Only disappointment - no neraval !!!!!! there should be reason for aishwarya to skip, to me it was disappointment. lack of time should not be a reason.

Such a wonderful support by sivaraman on mridangam and young girl in ghatam. Dr Narmada akka is just a shadow !! how she provide sruthi support while aishwarya singing, and violin reply comes how forecefully sangathis come out !! perfect example for packavadhyam (pacca vadhyam really)

Summing up - just everything perfect - did not over do anything, just because she had full control either in nadai variations, or singing 2nd kala swaram towards end of avarthanam in kambodhi swaras !

Sachi_R
Posts: 2188
Joined: 31 Jan 2017, 20:20

Re: S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Post by Sachi_R »

SirnathK
Your ease as you toss back phrases like a shadow point to an adeptness of on-line real-time expression that is the envy of ESPNCricinfo commentators!đź‘‹

Yes. There is need to invent keyboards on a mobile that toss back text like a shadow to your mental stream!

Bravo. Keep it up!

pattamaa
Posts: 750
Joined: 22 Nov 2009, 10:24

Re: S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Post by pattamaa »

Harsha bhogle of rasikas

Bhuvana Dinesh
Posts: 2
Joined: 18 Sep 2018, 11:58

Re: S Aishwarya and S Saundarya at Brahma Gana Sabha, Arkay Convention Center, 25/12/2018

Post by Bhuvana Dinesh »

The great grand daughters of MS AMMA....Aishwarya and Saundarya...presented a divine concert for Brahma Gana Sabha& BGS TRUST today evening..
Vathaapi in Hamsadhwani was the opening kriti with a blowing swaraprastharams from Aishwarya...
The Gaulipanthu, Therathiyakaradha was docile by both of them...followed by an aalap in Purvikalyani...with the kriti Anandhanatanamaduvar..
The swarams were stupendous by Aishwarya who very well managed the ghamakas and brighas through out in spite of her throat infection...
A fast paced Sindhuramakriya with the kriti devadhideva was a delivery to the perfection
The main piece Khambhoji...was the highlight with the sisters singing in 2 octaves the kriti...O Rangasayee ..
Aishwarya did full justice in lower and Saundarya in higher...
DR. M.Narmadha... the senior on the violin, was a gifted support to the young sisys....who by her charming smile was encouraging their energy...
Saundarya being a 8th standard student has an enormous talent and will achieve well with her hardwork...way to go...
Another youngster a school student on stage was the young Ghatam artist, Samyuktha sreeram from the US.
She was wonderful on her rhythms being a student of the ghatam Vidwan Sri. Subhash Chandra...
The thani by Sri. B. Sivaraman on the Mridangam and Samyuktha was brief and brisk...
Maithreem Bhajatha the MS AMMA's popularised song concluded the concert...

Post Reply