All times are UTC + 5:30 hours

Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 20 posts ] 
Author Message
Offline 
Post subject: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220834 Posted: 30 Apr 2012 08:58 

   Posts: 2579
   Location: Sydney, Australia
News reports about the resignation by Smt Leela Samson as Director of Kalakshetra

http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/a ... 361530.ece
and
http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp ... 368579.ece
and
http://www.thehindu.com/arts/dance/arti ... epage=true
and
http://www.thehindu.com/arts/dance/arti ... epage=true
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220853 Posted: 30 Apr 2012 14:50 

   Posts: 5850
Dance is not at all my world, but I don't think anybody who has ever encountered Leela Samson can fail to be impressed by her.

Whilst most say that she has done a wonderful job, I'm sure that the bitterness of a handful is hard to live with. I recall some trumped up nonsense from a few years ago: I'm sure there must be many that never make the news.

Hmmm... Aren't they looking for a new president just now? :)
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220894 Posted: 01 May 2012 08:14 

   Posts: 2579
   Location: Sydney, Australia
More at http://www.thehindu.com/arts/dance/arti ... epage=true
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220914 Posted: 01 May 2012 13:17 

   Posts: 5850
Ah, yes... read this with my morning tea today.

The plot thickens. Looks as if it has been pretty thick all along.
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220922 Posted: 01 May 2012 18:23 

   Posts: 211
   Location: New York
I too know little about dance, nor about Mrs. Leela Samson, who is a very talented artist by all accounts. However, I understand there is a lot of controversy about her attempts to remove Hindu symbolism from Bharatanatyam. See http://groups.yahoo.com/group/religious ... 3336?var=1 for some extracts from "Breaking India" by Rajeev Malhotra. If there is any truth in this, I think it is dangerous to have someone like her as the head of an institution like Kalakshetra.

Actually, I have issues with this whole concept of a "Ministry of Culture" which manages institutions that should be dedicated to the preservation of ancient arts in a "secular manner" and attempts to make these "accessible to all" by removing religious symbolism. Our music and dance is nothing but spiritual and devotional. It is a great disservice and a gross distortion to pretend otherwise, and a travesty to try to remake these centuries old classics in the modern fashion.

- Sreenadh
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220923 Posted: 01 May 2012 18:38 

   Posts: 5850
Just going by my sense of smell ... that piece of writing wreaks of prejudice, and is probably typical of the kind of stuff she has had to put up over the years. The extremism shines through: such people don't bother about truth, there are all too many of them around the world, under their various labels.

I wish one of our dance experts would tell us if there is any truth in it. Oddly, I remember something about the idols, and, I think that, if you google, you will find it to be a misrepresentation.

By the way, as all the usual prejudices flood all the usual minds including mine, I found out yesterday that she is not, as I had assumed, Christian. It seems that her background is in what I think of as the other truly ancient religion in the world.

Quote:
Our music and dance is nothing but spiritual and devotional. It is a great disservice and a gross distortion to pretend otherwise, and a travesty to try to remake these centuries old classics in the modern fashion.
So, you don't think that Pandit Birju Maharaj should be dancing telephone numbers on stage? You don't think there is room for anything else other than religious themes in classical dance?

I'm pleased that someone else showed some interest in this thread. Maybe the title is not explicit enough, but it seemed that the whole event was going to pass undiscussed on rasikas, with the only interest coming from Australia.
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220925 Posted: 01 May 2012 18:48 

   Posts: 2579
   Location: Sydney, Australia
There was a big discussion about this on Narthaki a while ago see http://narthaki.com/info/rt/rt8.html
now the same site has established a petition to keep Ms Samson in the role. http://www.narthaki.com/info/rt/rt48.html
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220926 Posted: 01 May 2012 18:56 

   Posts: 211
   Location: New York
Nick H wrote:
So, you don't think that Pandit Birju Maharaj should be dancing telephone numbers on stage? You don't think there is room for anything else other than religious themes in classical dance?


The telephone numbers reference escapes me, but no, I don't think that there is no room for non-religious themes in classical dance. I do think, though, that we need an institution dedicated to preserving the traditional form of Bharatanatyam, with its deeply spiritual, and specifically Hindu, symbolism. And Kalakshetra was founded to do this.

And I agree the piece I quoted (which was the first one that showed up when I googled) does smell. That is the problem with many articles of this type, that their shrillness often takes away from any valid points they're trying to make. I'd welcome comments by knowledgeable persons on this board on whether there is any truth in these allegations.

- Sreenadh


Last edited by ShrutiLaya on 01 May 2012 19:13, edited 1 time in total.
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220927 Posted: 01 May 2012 19:08 

   Posts: 211
   Location: New York
Maybe I was wrong and did not do enough digging around .. I found this piece in the Nartaki site (thanks to Mohan) at http://www.narthaki.com/info/rt/rt8a.html where one Vrnda Devi (her post is towards the bottom of the page) makes a strong rebuttal. Well .. who knows ..

- Sreenadh
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220928 Posted: 01 May 2012 19:13 

   Posts: 5850
I suspect you may be following a google trail that I too followed a while back!

I am surprised at the lack of contribution, in support or otherwise, on this thread. Whether we are dance people or not, (I'm not), isn't this an institution that matters to us as a community?
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220936 Posted: 02 May 2012 00:47 
   Rank: Moderator
   Posts: 8733
Remember the old adage that dispenses a very practical and important advice that a vast majority of the general public do not follow.. kaNNAl pArpadum poi, kAdAl kEtpadum poi...... ( what you see with your eyes is false, what you hear is false...... truth is to be discerned and judged after careful deliberation of all the info... ). In the Google age, we all need to take the oath that "the first link is false", "the audio link is false", "the video link is false" ;) Judge after careful consideration of many sources of information.. This is even more true in this kind of politically and culturally sensitive topics on the internet.
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220937 Posted: 02 May 2012 02:33 

   Posts: 5850
Very good point. Be a healthy cynic about everything, online and off
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220938 Posted: 02 May 2012 02:48 

   Posts: 9810
Let's not forget that kalAkshEtra is no longer a private institution as it was when Smt. RDA created it. It is now overseen by the GOI. So, who knows what the interactions were between Ms. Sampson and the GOI...IIRC, there were some reservations expressed when Ms. Sampson was appointed to the board of censors...If my opinion matters, it would indeed be the government's and kalAkshEtra's loss if her resignation is accepted.
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220940 Posted: 02 May 2012 06:36 

   Posts: 107
Leela’s no stranger to drama. Even Google’s first suggest result is “Leela Samson controversy.”

It's clear people have been out for blood ever since Leela started as director of Kalakshetra in 2005. First there was that whole drama about Leela displacing Ganesha idols, which the Hindu extremists twisted into an anti-Hindu attack. Then when Leela accepted the positions on the Central Board of Film Certification and Sangeet Natak Akademi, people questioned her ability to perform. And now this.

I'd like to know more about this CS Thomas, a former teacher of Kalakshetra who is weirdly interested in Leela's age. Even though the Union Ministry of Culture supported her, it seemed Leela had enough of the “lies, allegations, and games people play” and resigned anyway.

ShrutiLaya wrote:
Actually, I have issues with this whole concept of a "Ministry of Culture" which manages institutions that should be dedicated to the preservation of ancient arts in a "secular manner" and attempts to make these "accessible to all" by removing religious symbolism. Our music and dance is nothing but spiritual and devotional. It is a great disservice and a gross distortion to pretend otherwise, and a travesty to try to remake these centuries old classics in the modern fashion.

- Sreenadh


I don't think Kalakshetra should have an obligation towards preserving Hinduism and "these centuries old classics" because it goes against the very nature of the institution and what Rukmini Devi did. Since the beginning Rukmini made revolutionary changes to the art form, for example drastically modifying the Pandanallur style, removing "objectionable" elements, flaunting the guru-shishya tradition, promoting male dancers, promoting female nattuvanars, etc. It's my understanding that most of Kalakshetra's repertoire is fairly recent. To believe that Rukmini was preserving something is frankly delusional. Do you really think the Brahmin appropriation of the Devadasis' sacred art truly represents our ancient heritage in a non secular manner?

It doesn't matter anyway, there hasn't been evidence to support the Government's attempts secularize Kalakshetra.
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220950 Posted: 02 May 2012 10:48 

   Posts: 2579
   Location: Sydney, Australia
ardhanariswar wrote:

I'd like to know more about this CS Thomas


Doubting Thomas perhaps?
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220956 Posted: 02 May 2012 12:56 

   Posts: 5850
His involvement is covered in this link and seems to be connected with getting a job for his daughter.

I'm horribly aware that a post like this, informed by only a snippet from a newspaper article, could, itself, be just a baseless smear :o

To deal with this sort of thing on a regular basis must be frustrating in the extreme for a good administrator; for an artist, it must be soul destroying. She seems to have coped remarkably well
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 220957 Posted: 02 May 2012 15:21 

   Posts: 2579
   Location: Sydney, Australia
Not sure of what the management structure at Kalakshetra is but clearly they need some key positions such as Director of Administration
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 221037 Posted: 04 May 2012 14:26 

   Posts: 5850
The Hindu continues to cover the case:

Emergency meet of Kalakshetra board likely

Case of missing the wood…
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 221689 Posted: 18 May 2012 07:49 

   Posts: 2579
   Location: Sydney, Australia
Board has endorsed Leela Samson: http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/article3410671.ece
and she may reconsider: http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp ... 410680.ece
   
Offline 
Post subject: Re: Kalakshetra
  Post ID: 221887 Posted: 23 May 2012 04:33 

   Posts: 107
Leela Samson gave an interview and discussed in depth over what some of the issues were regarding her decision to leave Kalakshetra.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CWBUhkzVoO4 around the 18:00 minute mark.

I found her comments regarding the land mafia very interesting. Thoughts?
   
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic

All times are UTC + 5:30 hours

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users

Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group